When my team of researchers and I entered 27 schools in Blackpool, Hampshire and Ealing, our goal was simple – to produce research which would have a real impact on the 3,766 pupils, and potentially many more, whom we met during our research project. The challenge was, however, far from simple, as there are a myriad of design factors in play within every classroom. Disentangling the influence of these took every moment of the three years this study took to bring to a successful conclusion. But it was worth it. Although many people intuitively feel that classroom design is important for effective learning, we have now established the evidence for how important it is and which of the factors involved are particularly important.
So, how important is the classroom design? Based on the 153 classrooms we studied, we have discovered that variations in the physical characteristics of these rooms explains 16% of the variation in the learning progress of the pupils who spent a year in these spaces. In the extreme case of moving an “average” pupil from the least effective classroom to the mosteffective classroom, we estimate that it would add more than a national curriculum sub-level to their progress, over a year. This is a much bigger impact than we expected. So, to meet our original aim of improving the learning opportunities of primary school pupils, we have created a freely available guide [see bio] which provides illustrated advice to teachers and designers as to which factors are especially important.
To give you a flavour of this our top ten tips to innovate the classroom to be as effective a learning space as possible are set out below. Many of these tips are cheap to do and are easy to implement – once you have the evidence!
The first group of tips are to do with the naturalness, or healthiness, of the classroom. This is obvious in many ways, as to function well as learners we need to be well nourished – so what does this mean?
Tip 1 – Maximise Daylight
Daylight is good for us. Where you can it should be maximised, but subject of course to avoiding problems with glare. Obstructing the windows with large items of furniture or covering them with pupils’ work is not usually a good idea. Depending on the orientation and size of the windows in your classroom you may need to use blinds, but only as much as you have to. Of course, there will be times when artificial light is needed and good-quality lighting is important to keep up attention levels.
Tip 2 – Ensure Adequate Ventilation
Again, a very basic human requirement – oxygen! An average classroom with thirty children in it will develop poor air quality within 30 minutes if no fresh air is introduced. This is important as poor air makes pupils drowsy, not a good basis for learning. So opening windows as regularly as possible is recommended, as poor air quality was commonly encountered.
Tip 3 – Control the Temperature
Hopefully you have a thermostat in the classroom and can control your space to be cool but comfortable. If there are problems of overheating from the sun then external shading is the answer, as internal blinds come too late, after the heat has passed through the glass. Pragmatically, though, you may have to use a combination of blinds and ventilation.
The next two tips are to do with how well the classroom supports the pupils as individuals. How well can they relate to it as “their” space – after all, they do spend a large part of their time in it!
Tip 4 – Choose the Right Level Flexibility
A classroom that has defined learning zones, ones that are suited to the pupils’ stage of development, assists learning. Given the usual blended learning approach to teaching that we saw, this means a range of zones for the more play-based learning of KS1 children and bigger simpler spaces for KS2 pupils, as the learning becomes more formal. So, do you need more learning options – or maybe fewer?
Tip 5 – Engender Ownership
Having aspects of the classroom that reflect the individual pupils is important. Some of their work on the wall, names / pictures on drawers and pegs, etc. Also something that maybe they have created together that makes the classroom instantly recognisable – not just a soulless box. This is all supported by good quality, child-centred furniture and equipment. Lots of teachers do these things, and our evidence is that it really helps.
The next two tips focus on the level of background stimulation provided by the visual appearance of the classroom. Until now it has been argued by some that de-cluttering is best and by others that exciting spaces are best. In a good old-fashioned “moderation in all things” way, it turns out from the clear evidence of our research that somewhere in the middle is actually optimal.
Tip 6 – Manage the Visual Complexity
So, a mid-level of visual complexity is to be sought. This is a lot to do with the displays where you are aiming for a lively feel, without it becoming chaotic! As a rule of thumb, leaving something like 20-50% of the wall space clear is to be recommended. Of course the basic complexity of the floor plan and ceiling structure is your starting position and should be taken into account.
Tip 7 – Use Colour Carefully
Young children do seem to like bright colours, but for effective learning a combination of quite a calm background colour for the walls with some brighter highlights, say the teaching wall or a feature area, seems best. Then you have to factor in the effect of the furniture and displays etc. So just stand back and judge whether the colour scheme is “shouting at you”, feels really boring and bland or is just right, somewhere in the middle.
After all this detail, the last three tips are more general:
Tip 8 – Attack on All Fronts!
The impact on learning of the above actions is spread pretty evenly across all seven areas. So, don’t focus on one or two only, but try to assess and address all of them together. Not easy in a busy world, but once you have taken an initial view it will get easier. A large part of it is increased awareness to what matters – now we have established the evidence.
Tip 9 – Don’t Assume a “Good” School Means a “Good” Classroom
From our study we know that there are typically more and less effective classrooms in the same school. Sometimes it’s to do with the different orientations of classrooms and other times it comes from the different things individual teachers do with their spaces. So you should look at every classroom as an individual case. Design issues at a school level (shared facilities, playgrounds, etc) were not as important from our analysis as the factors at the classroom level – which is after all the primary school pupil’s universe!
Tip 10 – Remember to See the Classroom as Another Teaching Tool
All of the above can sound like the type of thing that a building surveyor would go on about. But, remember, these are the specific aspects that have been shown to have positive (and, if ignored, potentially negative) impacts on learning. You and your pupils need all the help you can get to enhance learning, so hopefully the physical features of the classroom will now feel more like a set of levers you can pull to positive effect.